Borderland Beat |  |
- Argentine Forensics Team Says First Remains Are Not of Ayotzinapa Students
- The Bodies of 11 Youths Found Abandoned In Guerrero
- On this Thanksgiving Day, Inspirational words left behind, by a life brutally taken
| Argentine Forensics Team Says First Remains Are Not of Ayotzinapa Students Posted: 27 Nov 2014 12:57 PM PST Borderland Beat posted by DD Republished from The Mexico Blog of the CIP Americas Program, By Laura Carlson  Finally, the Argentine forensics team called in as an independent analyst by human rights groups and parents of the missing students of Aytozinapa, has weighed in. The Team announced today that it analyzed 24 of the 30 remains discovered in Cerro Viejo in six graves outside Iguala, Guerrero and none are of the missing students. "El EEAF has obtained genetic results from the laboratory The Bode Technology Group in the United States on 24 of the 30 remains recovered in Cierro Viejo. None of those showed probability of biological parentage with the 43 students of the rural college. Work continues on the six additional remains and results are expected soon." This result concurs with the findings of the Federal Attorney General's office announced on Oct. 14 that the remains were not of the students. The Argentine team states in its comuniqué that it has participated in the exhumation of 2 of the 30 bodies found at Cierro Viejo, 1 of the 9 found at La Parota and in recovery of remains at the dump in Cocula. The process-of-elimination method of identification now leaves the Parota bodies and the Cocula bodies--and any others that might turn up as the search continues in a region that has come to be known as a narco-cemetery. AG Jesus Murillo Karam announced on Nov. 7 that detailed testimony from criminals led to the Cocula dump, where --again, according to the criminals--the students were killed, their bodies incinerated, bagged and tossed in a nearby river and other sites. Murillo Karam stated that those remains have been sent to a lab in Innsbruck. It is not clear why they were sent to a different lab, if the Argentine team is testing remains from that site separately or how long this identification will take. Although the announcement that 24 of the first remains found are not the students provides the first scientific certainty to the case, it still leaves far more questions than answers. First, the AG office found the Cierro Viejo remains on the basis of testimony by members of the Guerreros Unidos drug cartel arrested after the crime who said they had driven the students there and murdered them. So the federal government investigators were either duped by the criminals or arranged the exhumations of the wrong bodies as a distraction or a feint, as many of the Ayotzinapa students and families claim. Parents had long been skeptical of the first claims, stating what we now know--that some of the remains were female and that the age ranges were wrong. Suspicions are now deepened. If criminal testimony proved false the first time, how reliable can it be now that three new cartel members are claiming with graphic detail that they killed the students at the Cocula dump? The parents have already stated firmly and angrily that they will not accept criminal testimony as a resolution of the case. They maintain that their sons are alive until there is irrefutable scientific proof that the remains are of their loved ones. So far, no matches have been made. The communiqué of Nov.11 concludes: "In synthesis, up to now there have been no identifications between the remains found in the 3 locations mentioned and the 43 students. The EEAF continues to work on efforts to identify the recovered remains, alongside official investigations. The institutional policy of the EAAF is to inform results first to the the families of the victims, and to the authorities in charge of the investigations." The last statement could be a concern. Does the team have to have the OK from the authorities to announce its findings, or just chronologically inform them first before going public? The problem with the process of elimination method of identification in Guerrero is that the state seems to be capable of producing an untold number of cadavers to eliminate. The task of connecting these to other disappeared people will be complicated, to say the least. Record-keeping is poor and DNA testing extremely limited. A persistent accusation dogging the AG in recent weeks is that the government and his office in particular is "managing the crisis" rather than resolving it. That is to say, that it has failed to reveal what it knows and is in the throes not of a real search but of a political dilemma regarding whether it's best to keep the students alive in the public eye or produce evidence of death. The latter prolongs the situation of uncertainty that is feeding demonstrations and actions across the country; the former s admission of a massacre and could ignite even greater public indignation and rage. Notably, the message from the Argentine team does not indicate that the Cocula remains might be too deteriorated to be analyzed. The government has hinted at the possiblity--the latest version of the criminals' testimony indicates they went to great lengths to assure the bodies not be identified. It will be vitally important to identify the rest of the remains quickly and reliably. The Aytozinapa families need that, and so do the thousands of families of other disappeared persons whose bodies anonymously in clandestine graves. Like the ones of Cierro Viejo.  |
| The Bodies of 11 Youths Found Abandoned In Guerrero Posted: 27 Nov 2014 10:05 AM PST  Translated by Valor for Borderlandbeat By: Rogelio Agustín/ Víctor Hugo Michel/Ezequiel Flores Contreras Ministerial Police found the bodies of 11 youths on a dirt road that connects the county seat of Chilapa with the population of Ayahualulco, very close to a security guardhouse belonging to the preventive police. The discovery was reported this morning (November 27), even though there were reports of at least two different confrontations in the neighborhood of La Villa, near the preparatory school #26. The criminal groups reported to be involved in the clashes are "Los Rojos" and "Los Ardillos". "Los Ardillos" are reported to be directing the brothers of the president of the local Congress, and the local PRD congressman Bernardo Ortega Jiménez. The bodies belonged to men between the ages of 20 and 25, all of them receiving R-15 and AK-47 shots. According to official reports, the victims were lying on the shoulder of the road, decapitated, dismembered, and burned. Other reports say that some were doused in fuel but were unsuccessfully incinerated. Even though the clashes were reported to be on the evening of the 26th, the bodies didn't appear until dawn and had a message from one of the organized crime groups operating in the area. The message read: "There goes your trash ha ha ha…Fucking Ardillos shitty turncoats. Atte. The big shot." Heading towards Santa Catarina, a military patrol arrested a civilian who was carrying firearms and grenades. Photo on next page   |
| On this Thanksgiving Day, Inspirational words left behind, by a life brutally taken Posted: 27 Nov 2014 12:04 PM PST Chivis Martinez Borderland Beat  Readers, My time in Mexico and contributing to Borderland Beat, has given me countless remarkable experiences and the opportunity to meet some unforgettable, amazing people. Two of those people are two brave women, both named Ann. One Ann is the sister of James Stacy, who was kidnapped in January of this year, on the highway of death in Tamaulipas. Ann and her mother searched valiantly and exhaustively for word of James. James' bank account was drained of its funds. I received word from Ann in August that their search was coming to an end. James mother's health had declined, and they had reached an impasse in the search. I felt it was a good decision. James mother had wanted to travel to Tamaulipas to search, for several reasons I advised against this action. The other Ann is the mother of Harry Devert, kidnapped in Michoacán or Guerrero on the same day as James Stacy. We know that he was murdered and buried in Guerrero. Ann's tenacity and determination to "find" her only child took her to Mexico, where she was relentless in being public, being seen, sending a message to those who had taken her son, she was not going away until she had answers. I believe it was because of her stomping the grounds, and being relentless in hounding every agency of Mexico, US and France, is why the anonymous call was eventually made, as to where Harry's body could be found. There were three memorials for Harry, one in Mexico, New York and France. It was in France that his ashes were scattered. Harry's life or rather the manner in which he lived life was remarkable. He lived as though something inside urged him not to waste a minute. His joy of life reaches out an embraces those who read his words. An amazing son from an amazing mother. I tell Ann that she is the mother I hope I am, the mother I aspire to be, and in a perfect world, the mother every child should be blessed with... At top is a photo of Harry featuring his words, click on image to enlarge. Have a wonderful Thanksgiving, feel your blessings, love big, and live your life with great joy.  |
| You are subscribed to email updates from Borderland Beat To stop receiving these emails, you may unsubscribe now. | Email delivery powered by Google |
| Google Inc., 1600 Amphitheatre Parkway, Mountain View, CA 94043, United States | |
No comments:
Post a Comment